Reviewer Roles and Responsibility

Reviewers Role and Responsibilities

Responsibilities Of Reviewers 

1 Reviewers play a crucial role in providing an unbiased evaluation of a submitted manuscript and determining whether it contributes significantly to the field, warranting publication.

2 Reviewers are expected to adhere to specific timelines in order to provide timely and relevant feedback.

3 One of the reviewer's responsibilities is to assess the relevance of the work to the journal in which it is being submitted.

4 Reviewers also evaluate the originality of the article and ensure that it brings something new to the field.

5 It is important for reviewers to verify that all relevant work is properly cited and discussed in the manuscript.

6 Reviewers must carefully examine the methodology used in the study and ensure that it is appropriate and adequately described.

7 Another important aspect of the review process is to determine whether the conclusions drawn by the authors are supported by the reported results.

8 Reviewers are also responsible for checking if any necessary statistical analyses have been conducted and reported correctly.

9 Reviewers should assess the clarity and comprehensibility of the paper, even if the English language proficiency of the authors is not perfect.

10 Lastly, reviewers need to thoroughly review the manuscript and identify any errors or inconsistencies in scientific notations, equations, figures, diagrams, Graphs, Bar chart and References.

Reviewers Perspective

When reviewing a manuscript, it is important to consider factors such as Grammar, references editing, results explanation, and figure reformatting for both major and minor revisions. Reviewers have the authority to reject a manuscript if it is found to be based on false presentation and lacks scientific evidence. On the other hand, manuscripts are deemed acceptable if they are well-written, easy to comprehend, supported by results, and contribute significantly to existing published knowledge.